Cardinal Heenan - to him the Church meant "authority" - and so it should
Picture: A Reluctant Sinner
I mean what would Cardinal Heenan have done in the sense of action over the gay "marriage" fiasco, or the gay Masses in Soho, Catholic Adoption Agencies caving in to government legislation, Catholic schools being cesspits of ignorance regarding the Faith, the Pathway to oblivion touted by Liverpool, the general lethargy of the hierarchy when it comes to standing up for Christ, being a witness to the Church Militant.
Well, he would not have remained silent.
He was always on television fighting the good fight.
He made acute observations regarding the new Mass in the vernacular ("the men won't go you know") although I am unsure as to why he didn't think that the women also would not go.
He it was who did more than any person other than, possibly, Mother Theresa, to bring broadcaster and intellectual, Malcolm Muggeridge into the fold.
The late Cardinal Heenan was a scrapper but always in a kind way. He gave witness to the Faith straight from the shoulder; he would not have waited until the last minute to issue a letter regarding the Church's view on same-sex marriage.
And I doubt Mr Barber would be getting his knees under the desk at the Catholic Education Service if the good Cardinal was still Archbishop of Westminster.
The following conversation is between the Cardinal and Malcolm Muggeridge before he jumped into the Tiber.
It gives an excellent insight into both men, it is amusing and forthright.
In answer to Muggeridge's question "Presumably you want people to become Roman Catholic?" His Eminence answers: "Yes. I want everybody to" - a no nonsense response, full of Christian love both for his Faith and for others.
Extract from Muggeridge: Through the Microphone; BBC Radio and Television,
Edited by Christopher Ralling.
Muggeridge: I always feel that
almost the only reason that I’d like to become a Cardinal would be to be waited
on by nuns.
Cardinal: I think you’d make a
very good Cardinal as a matter of fact.
Muggeridge: I doubt it strongly.
Not a Cardinal, perhaps a bishop.
Cardinal: Well, you’ve got to
start somewhere.
Muggeridge: I always like lunching
on Fridays because we don’t have meat.
Cardinal: You’re not getting any
fish, by the way, you’re getting an omelette.
Muggeridge: No, no, it’s very nice.
This would be part of the Catholic life that I would find least difficult. I
suppose it dates from a time when eating meat was a tremendously important
thing.
Cardinal: Well, you know what
they say. They say that it was an example of the Jewish instinct of the twelve
Apostles; they were all fishermen, and they decided that if they made a rule
about fish on Fridays, it would be good business. But I don’t think that’s a
theological doctrine.
Muggeridge: How powerful is a
Cardinal today?
Cardinal: How powerful? It really
depends on what you mean by power.
Muggeridge: But aren’t you the boss
of the bishops?
Cardinal: The boss of the
bishops? No, the Pope is.
Muggeridge: But he’s your boss?
Cardinal: The Pope is my boss,
but he’s also the boss of all the bishops. The Pope deals directly with the
bishops, not through me necessarily.
Muggeridge: He can go over your
head as it were?
Cardinal: Well, yes. I wouldn’t
think of it in that way.
Muggeridge: No. But the thing is
that of course the Church does indulge in the sort of magnificence and outward
show which one associates with worldly power.
Cardinal: When you’re taking part
in ritual, as I do very often, it is burdensome rather than self-glorifying.
Muggeridge: You mean you personally
don’t like it too much?
Cardinal: Well, no, and also
you’ve got to wear the robes. The same as the poor Queen when she wears the
crown and the royal robes. I’m sure she’s most uncomfortable but nevertheless
she knows that by doing this she gives a certain satisfaction to her people.
Muggeridge: To me, at any rate,
such emulation of the trappings of earthly authority would seem to have a
certain danger.
Cardinal: This outward panoply
and foolishness that you are thinking of, this has its uses, because even
sticking a chain round a man’s neck and calling him mayor of Wigan – I don’t
mean that with any disrespect to Wigan, of course – but putting a chain round a
man’s neck marks him out as chief citizen. If he’s not a fool he doesn’t really
think he’s the brightest and best and best and most intelligent man in that
particular town. Nevertheless, that chain of office shows him to be what he is;
it’s a sign – a badge of his office. Incidentally, I’ve got a chain on too,
with a Cross, and I always envy a Mayor his chain, because at the end of the
year he can just take it off and go off on his own, but this thing will be with
me until I’m in the coffin in the Cathedral…
Muggeridge: How about
your role as proselytizer?
Cardinal: I loathe that word.
Muggeridge: Presumably you want
more people to become Roman Catholics?
Cardinal: Yes. I want everybody
to.
Muggeridge: Therefore you are a
sort of missionary.
Cardinal: I object to the word
proselytizer because it sounds like something very underhand, some poison, some
snaky movement by which you’re trying to drag people from the truth and
indoctrinate them….No, you wouldn’t call Christ a proselytizer; a preacher
perhaps. We call the Apostles –
Muggeridge: Evangelists.
Cardinal: Evangelists, men who
have the message, which they believe to be truth, and want to spread it
everywhere. Now there’s nothing strange about that, because even if you
happened to have discovered a cough cure and it really works, and you take this
thing, this drug or injection, all winter, and never have a cold, you know well
that you cannot stop telling your friends about it. If you’re a good man and
you possess a good thing, you want to share it. There’s an old philosophical
saying, Bonum est diffusivum sui. You’ll know this, of course, but for the sake
of my colleagues on the bench I will translate. It means that goodness diffuses
itself, spreads itself, it can’t help it, just as heat can’t help expanding,
warmth glows. In this kind of way a person who possesses the faith wants to
spread it, want his warmth to go out to others. Now that’s no problem to me. Is
it a problem to you?
Muggeridge: No, not a problem at
all.
Cardinal: But this is what you’ve
got to remember. Although we don’t use the word because it’s an offensive kind
of word to use, this country’s full of pagans, this country’s full of people
who know as little about God as the so-called heathens that you mentioned.
Muggeridge: Since you would hold
that your Church in certain respects has the message uniquely, you would
presumably wish good Anglicans also to join it.
Cardinal: Well naturally; after
all this country was once a completely Catholic country, as you know. It would
be lovely if once again it would be a completely Catholic country, from my
point of view. Whereas, as you know, others would say, ‘Oh no, just a moment,
it was once a Catholic country, but the corruption of Rome spread, and it has
to be cured by a complete revival and renewal, and then the old Catholic faith
was restored and Romanism dissipated.’ That’s another point of view – not, as
it happens, mine.
Muggeridge: I didn’t think it was.
Anyway, the point is that presumably, in so far as you would in the long run
hope to bring back the Anglican church into the fold, into the Roman Catholic
fold, that would mean that you were a missionary in relation to them also; that
even the Archbishop of Canterbury, say, is a target.
Cardinal: Well, target is hardly
the word.
Muggeridge: How do you get along
with him, incidentally?
Cardinal: He’s a very great
friend of mine; I’m very fond of him, and of his wife too.
Muggeridge: Do you argue with him
when you’re there?
Cardinal: I don’t think we argue
in the sense of having controversy. It’s clear that as the Chief Bishop of the
Church, the Anglican Church in this country and throughout the world, it’s
hardly likely that when I go to Lambeth I would go with a whole bundle of
tracts in my pocket and say, ‘Look, I must explain to you about Papal
Infallibility.’ Of course not. Our conversation is on a very different level,
and I don’t think he ever seriously tries to persuade me of the errors of Rome or offer me a job as his assistant or auxiliary
bishop in Canterbury.
No, we don’t do that. But if you ask me, I don’t want to appear in any way
insincere. I do agree that my greatest desire would be to have all Englishmen
Catholics again.
Muggeridge: And those little
churches and cathedrals that used to be Catholic – all their bells would be
ringing.
Cardinal: You’ve got to
be quite mature before you realize what being a priest involves, particularly
in the question of celibacy, giving up the right to a family and so on, and
it’s at that time, I think that the crisis comes with most people. These young
men realize, they might be 20, 19, 21, anything, but they’ll be quite mature
and they will then say, ‘Now, for the first time I realize that this really
does mean a lonely life.’ You’re not feeling miserable because you’re alone,
but you’re a man apart.
The relationship between a Catholic priest and his people is
something you’ve got to experience to understand, they call me Father and
that’s a term of tremendous affection. Now that Fatherhood I find enormously
attractive and uplifting, but the shouting and the kissing, that means very
little indeed.
Muggeridge: What do people want
from their religion?
Cardinal: It’s the unchanging
teaching of the Church which answers the deepest appeal, I think, in the heart
of the people.
Muggeridge: What is that unchanging
teaching, in a word?
Cardinal: In a word, if you want
a word – authority.
Muggeridge: Authority, whose
authority?
Cardinal: The authority of the
Church, made known through the Pope and through the Council.
Muggeridge: Contrasting with that,
when you’re standing at the altar…?
Cardinal: Now that’s quite
different. When I’m standing at the altar, I am there representing Christ. When
I offer the Mass, I don’t say, ‘This is the Body of Christ,’ I say, ‘This is my
Body,’ because I, John Heenan, don’t exist. That’s why the vestments are there
to disguise my personality. I am standing there a mediator, as
one representing
Christ. That’s quite different; there I am the Church, so to speak.
Muggeridge: This is the difficult
thing to understand.
Cardinal: Of course, of course.
Muggeridge: I mean, how do you
feel, when you’re doing it?
Cardinal: Well, I’ve been a
priest for thirty-five years, and I’ve offered Mass every day.
Muggeridge: For thirty-five years.
Cardinal: Yes, and sometimes more
than once a day. Now there’s an old saying, an old Latin saw, – Ab ssuetis non
fit passio – a thing you’re used to doesn’t affect you, and so, obviously, I
don’t feel emotionally now as I did the day I put on vestments for the first
time, and offered my first Mass as a young priest. I don’t feel the same but
perhaps I treasure the Mass even more; the Mass means more to me now after
thirty-five years of celebration daily, than it did then. But how to describe
that and how to show that that should be so is very difficult.
Muggeridge: Does it add to your
worries when you think that by and large people are falling away from the
Christian religion?
Cardinal: Of course, of course. I
don’t use the word worry, because I don’t worry about these things. It’s God’s
business, you know. If they’re falling away from religion, they’re falling away
from Him.
Muggeridge: But you wouldn’t feel
that it’s because you’re being inadequate?
Cardinal: Yes, yes.
Muggeridge: Do you, when you wake
up in the night, think that…
Cardinal: How do you know I wake
up in the night?
Muggeridge: I’m sure you’re a
fellow-insomniac. I can spot them. When you wake up, would it be a bad thing
that would worry you to think to yourself, ‘Well, are we really making a great
mistake’?
Cardinal: No, I don’t. On this,
no. I have no doubts whatsoever.
Muggeridge: You would regard
yourself as being a person who held, on the whole, for tradition?
Cardinal: Well yes, I would say
that every Catholic really at heart values the tradition. You can’t be a
Catholic without holding for tradition. We’re the one thing in a changing world
that’s solid. We’re the thing that people can reach for.
Muggeridge: But you are going to go
on being as solid as you have been?
Cardinal: I hope so. Of course we
are. Rome is
the centre of Christianity. This place is still the centre, and that’s not
because of that material building. Because, you see, this city of Rome could be taken over
by the communists tomorrow, or next year. But even if materially we abandoned Rome, the spiritual centre of the Church is the Pope, the
Vicar of Christ, and, as you know, there have been Popes that have never seen Rome. At one time there
were no less than three people claiming to be the Pope. There was vice in this Vatican. This
was a centre of vice from time to time, the Borgia Popes and so on, and
therefore we are sometimes inclined to think that this was the most wicked of
all ages, but in fact, in many ways, it’s the best of all ages. And you asked
some time ago where I stood, and was I against progress. The answer is no. But
obviously when you get people emotionally charges and determined to broaden the
view, there are going to be excesses, they’re going to exaggerate, they’re
going to get it wrong, and some of us have got to stand quite firm and say,
‘Yes, I love this wide open view, but we mustn’t for a moment forget truth, we
mustn’t pretend that truth doesn’t matter.
